Discussion about this post

User's avatar
kicorse's avatar

Good to see Joshua not only makes fantastic music, but also has good insights. Some great responses to some odd questions. I particularly love what Joshua said about basing musical interests about genre being harmful. The best musicians, and especially the best songwriters, tend to love music that's completely different to what they make. They are elite musicians, but never get into elitist silos.

It makes sense to me that he loves parts of the Japanese scene, because this is probably its biggest strength. If an American band made music like Band-Maid (specifically, the freedom to draw from any genre at any moment and seamlessly blend it into the music, and the extreme attention to detail without losing emotional impact), they would be acclaimed to the rooftops, because people wouldn't have to get over the prejudices that are evident in the question. But it's much harder for an American band to do that, because the "us and them" attitude between different genres creates a stifling creative environment. Good for Joshua for being more diplomatic that me, but still giving an eloquent rebuttal, and also for being someone who will hopefully lead the American music scene in a better direction.

No posts

Ready for more?